A (somewhat) American perspective from Israel and the Middle East
Settling Palestine: The ‘latest colonizing adventure’
The following is an excerpt from a documentary detailing the tactics employed by Jewish settlers in Palestine:
“When a new settlement is established, it must withstand attack from the very first day of occupation. A system of defense has been evolved, in which these experienced settlers play an important part.
“When the proposed site has been marked out, members of the established settlements in the vicinity move off to congregate in the village nearest the scene of the latest colonizing adventure. From all around they come. Men, who have themselves recently made pioneering history, by cars, lorries and wagons, they all move to the assembly point. The point from which, in the still of night, they will set out to roll back still further the carpet of desert waste.”
The film, of course, is an early Zionist propaganda piece from 1939. The descriptions of tactics, however, are just as accurate today as they were nearly three-quarters of a century ago.
What some might find shocking — or amusing — are the changes in the narrative and terminology-driven framework used to describe the Zionist settlement enterprise in the past 74 years.
Were the phrase “latest colonizing adventure” to be used in a documentary on settlements today, surely a host of “Hasbara” social media specialists, quasi-journalists and bloggers would summarily declare the filmmaker a pro-Palestinian, a “delegitimizer” of Israel, and at least one article would surely lodge an accusation or two of anti-Semitism.
Just like today, albeit sans historical context and an understanding that Palestine was not a land without a people, the film pays lip service to the displacement and/or land theft that is almost always part and parcel of renegade settlement construction.
“Armed guards watch with interest as the plowshare turns the first plow. An agricultural settlement is being reborn … The tower is up and the new settlement provides a background of permanence to the Arab neighbors driving their cattle back in the setting sun.”
Here is the 27-minute film. Enjoy.
Follow Michael Omer-Man on Twitter: @MikeOmerMan
| Print article | This entry was posted by Michael Omer-Man on January 4, 2013 at 2:55 pm, and is filed under Israeli Politics. Follow any responses to this post through RSS 2.0. You can leave a response or trackback from your own site. |
No trackbacks yet.
Tzipi Livni throws cold water on prospects for peace
about 3 months ago - No comments
Tzipi Livni, the only person in the soon-to-be-formed Israeli government who genuinely believes in the importance of the two-state peace process, splashed cold water on the prospect of it ever happening Tuesday. It’s time to start looking at alternative plans in case a two-state solution with the Palestinians proves impossible, she said. Speaking at the
EU diplomats to Brussels: Put your money where your mouth is
about 3 months ago - No comments
At face value, the European Union heads of mission report on the Israeli settlement enterprise is a scathing indictment and call to action against Israel’s illegal settlement activities. In between the lines, however, the report reflects a frustration by European diplomats and bureaucrats at their own governments’ inaction. They are not implementing the existing legislation,
Why Israel is – and will continue – trying to keep ‘Prisoner X’ a secret
about 4 months ago - No comments
This piece was first published on +972 Magazine. As details about the life, work and untimely demise of ‘Prisoner X’ unravel, the most intriguing unanswered questions remain: why did Israel secretly imprisoned him and why he is dead? But the details of the story appear to be making one thing clear; Israel’s security services likely
Could UNHRC’s settlement report put the ‘S’ back in BDS?
about 4 months ago - No comments
The UNHRC-sanctioned International Fact Finding Mission’s report on Israeli settlements is by no means the harshest UN document on Israel. But its last paragraph introduces one element that previously existed only in small pro-Palestinian and human rights activist circles. Namely, it puts the “S” back in BDS. The Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions campaign has had
Netanyahu, E-1 and the problem with democracy
about 6 months ago - No comments
One big problem with democracy — in most of its forms — is that leaders can be tempted to put their own re-election above the state’s civic and diplomatic interests. Israeli Prime Minister Binyamin Netanyahu’s decision-making in recent days may be one of the finest examples of the phenomenon. Every Israeli government for the past
Honest, ugly discourse: Gilad Sharon and John Stewart Mill
about 6 months ago - 1 comment
One of the responsibilities of the news media is to set the parameters of acceptable discourse in society. But while media outlets have the unique ability to demarcate what is and isn’t acceptable to print, in doing so, they walk a fine line and risk masking the ugliest – but real – faces of society.
Gaza: New rules in an old war
about 7 months ago - 1 comment
There’s something different about the most recent flare-up between Israel and Palestinian groups in the Gaza Strip. The Palestinians’ modus operandi appears to have changed, and Israel seems to be unsure of how to respond. In the past month, armed Palestinian groups in Gaza launched a string of three, seemingly well planned and ultimately successful
Iran: A game gone too far
about 9 months ago - 1 comment
The story of how Israel reached the – real or perceived – brink of war with Iran is not exactly what it appears to be. At some point in recent years, Israeli decision-makers decided to play a game. Through a fairly innocuous and innocent lens, the game can be described as “good cop, bad cop.”
‘Down with Oslo’ (and the PA?)
about 11 months ago - No comments
Nearly two decades have passed since the Oslo Accords first gave the world hope for Mideast peace and an end to Israeli rule over the Palestinian territories; in the West Bank, the failed framework for peace talks has become directly associated with the occupation itself. When hundreds of Palestinians took to the streets last week
Israel admits ‘administrative detention’ is unnecessary
about 1 year ago - No comments
Less than three weeks after at least 1,400 Palestinians in Israeli prisons launched a widespread hunger strike, Israeli Public Security Minister Yitzhak Aharonovitch on Thursday made several astounding admissions regarding Israel’s use of administrative detention. In private meetings with security officials, Aharonovitch called for reducing Israel’s use of the practice, applying it “only if there
about 5 months ago
So the nice Arabs come out to see the new place that was not there yesterday and the Arab boys wish that they could “join the fun” and the Arab herders wend their way home in the evening. To where? To those villages already there that we cannot see because they are not really there. Bedouins, all of ‘em. So who or what is attacking? “A ring of stone to safeguard civilization against the desert.” Back then the only good desert was a dead desert. Very enlightening. Notice how the narrative refers to the land as “Palestine.” Thanks for dredging this up from the archives.